Gay Muslim in straight marriage
Publié : mer. 26 juil. 2006 11:43
j'ai navigué sur Internet et voila ce que je trouvais dans un forum : un gay musulman qui veut comprendre la situation de l'islam envers ça et la réponse qu'il a eu :
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Question : Gay Muslim in straight marriage
Assalamu'alaikum, Brothers n Sisters
Thanx for all the thoughtful replies to my original message about being homosexual. What I would now like to know is this- if Allah, as part of the test, chooses to make me stay homosexual for a very long time (possibly until old age), how can I marry? Although I have refrained from homo acts for so long, I might still, as part of the Test Allah has given me, have sexual desires for men. In that case, what about marriage? In Islam, aren't we supposed to get married? And if I am gay, how can I get married without lying to my wife, or at least letting her know that the man who she sleeps with does not actually desire her? Perhaps as well as refraining from homosexual acts, I should refrain from marriage too, since I cannot think of any woman who would want to marry a homosoxual man.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Réponse:
Bismihi Ta'ala,
Assalaamu 'alaikum,
In Al-Islam marriage is not required (wajib) but is rather highly recommended (mustahhab). It is the Sunnah of the Prophet (may Allah bless him and grant him peace), and there is much reward in it beyond simply restraining from sexual desires.
Nevertheless, there are many Muslims who never get married; history even records some of the greatest scholars never married. Imam Nawawi, the famous hadith scholar of Ahlus-sunnah, for example, never married. So, if remaining unmarried is the best course for you (even if just for the time being), then it is not sinful to do so.
It is possible, however, that you could get married and have some of the benefits of marriage, even if sexual fulfillment is not one of them. I would not recommend you marry a woman who has sexual desires for men, if you are not attracted to her. However, the are women out there who are like you (having homosexual desires) or who do not have desires for men because of biological/genetic anomalies. You could marry someone like this and the two of you could enjoy halal companionship, while also helping each other refrain from haram activity.
Allah knows best what is the proper course of action for you. The ultimate goal is to please Him, and also not cause harm to yourself or others.
With prayers for your success!
wasalaam,
Adib
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
je commente: la réponse c'était ( il y a dans l'islam beaucoup d'immams non mariés, donc fais comme eux, abstiens toi, sinon, tu peux chercher une fille qui est lesbienne, tu te marie avec elle, et comme ça vous vous entraidez pour vous abstenir et éviter le Haram )
:mais dis moi, qu'est ce qu'il peut faire avec sa femme, ils vont jouer à la poupée ? que c'est rédicule cette réponse, donc s'abstenir vaut mieux s'épanouir ?
ne pas aimer et être frustré et avoir la haine contre toute l'humanité vaut mieux d'aimer et faire la paix ?
abstiens toi une semaine, et surtout abstiens toi de ta main, ne te masturbe pas pour tricher, je crains que tu vas chercher après à sauter la première qui passe,une fille, une chèvre, une anesse, tellement tu n'en peux plus, et après tu vas te laver pour te purifier et te déculpabiliser, espèce d'hypocrite !
http://www.muslimmessage.net/discussion ... opic=989.0
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Question : Gay Muslim in straight marriage
Assalamu'alaikum, Brothers n Sisters
Thanx for all the thoughtful replies to my original message about being homosexual. What I would now like to know is this- if Allah, as part of the test, chooses to make me stay homosexual for a very long time (possibly until old age), how can I marry? Although I have refrained from homo acts for so long, I might still, as part of the Test Allah has given me, have sexual desires for men. In that case, what about marriage? In Islam, aren't we supposed to get married? And if I am gay, how can I get married without lying to my wife, or at least letting her know that the man who she sleeps with does not actually desire her? Perhaps as well as refraining from homosexual acts, I should refrain from marriage too, since I cannot think of any woman who would want to marry a homosoxual man.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Réponse:
Bismihi Ta'ala,
Assalaamu 'alaikum,
In Al-Islam marriage is not required (wajib) but is rather highly recommended (mustahhab). It is the Sunnah of the Prophet (may Allah bless him and grant him peace), and there is much reward in it beyond simply restraining from sexual desires.
Nevertheless, there are many Muslims who never get married; history even records some of the greatest scholars never married. Imam Nawawi, the famous hadith scholar of Ahlus-sunnah, for example, never married. So, if remaining unmarried is the best course for you (even if just for the time being), then it is not sinful to do so.
It is possible, however, that you could get married and have some of the benefits of marriage, even if sexual fulfillment is not one of them. I would not recommend you marry a woman who has sexual desires for men, if you are not attracted to her. However, the are women out there who are like you (having homosexual desires) or who do not have desires for men because of biological/genetic anomalies. You could marry someone like this and the two of you could enjoy halal companionship, while also helping each other refrain from haram activity.
Allah knows best what is the proper course of action for you. The ultimate goal is to please Him, and also not cause harm to yourself or others.
With prayers for your success!
wasalaam,
Adib
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
je commente: la réponse c'était ( il y a dans l'islam beaucoup d'immams non mariés, donc fais comme eux, abstiens toi, sinon, tu peux chercher une fille qui est lesbienne, tu te marie avec elle, et comme ça vous vous entraidez pour vous abstenir et éviter le Haram )
:mais dis moi, qu'est ce qu'il peut faire avec sa femme, ils vont jouer à la poupée ? que c'est rédicule cette réponse, donc s'abstenir vaut mieux s'épanouir ?
ne pas aimer et être frustré et avoir la haine contre toute l'humanité vaut mieux d'aimer et faire la paix ?
abstiens toi une semaine, et surtout abstiens toi de ta main, ne te masturbe pas pour tricher, je crains que tu vas chercher après à sauter la première qui passe,une fille, une chèvre, une anesse, tellement tu n'en peux plus, et après tu vas te laver pour te purifier et te déculpabiliser, espèce d'hypocrite !
http://www.muslimmessage.net/discussion ... opic=989.0